Advaita and Hegel (linguistic implication)

In sanskrit grammar there are three types of implication

ajahati Lakhsan (implication by exclusion)- original meaning of the world is totally substituted
Jahati Lakshana (implication by non-exclusion)- original meaning of the world is not substituted, but a new connotation is attached to the 

The third approach is called bhaga tyaga lakshana (literally 'abandoning parts') and it corresponds nicely to hegelian sublation. 

There is a truth in the bare linguistic expression of the sentence, but it is unrefined. It is in the process of thinking through and interpreting it that the truth is refined and 'lifted' aufhebung to a higher unity.

This is how the mahavakyas are to be interpreted in the upanishads. 

Everything that is written, is written in the hope that someone else may read it, but writing words down necessary kills some part of the truth you know. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

An Open Letter to Somebody

You were just a kid.  Society told you you were smart. You were good at the mathy stuff. The grownups liked it when they told you two numbers and you could add them really fast. They subtly encouraged you, to study more. Feed the machine.  Or maybe you were not smart. You realized that the world goes around smart kids. They compared you, with your siblings, your classmates your relatives. They gave you examples of striking personalities, feeding the tendrils of ambition in your tender mind. I want to be like X when I grow up. I will grow up and become successful. They never defined successful for you. You were implicitly promised that you would be loved and everyone would be nice to you when you finally became "someone".  Maybe like many of us, you fell into their trap. You worked on being good at something you didn't enjoy so that you could be better off than others, and finally they could give you some love. Respect comes with money, status and power they told you. If y
Read more

Stressed Out

 Hello again to a random rant of which the only redeeming factor is in my opinion the fact that it is as unfiltered as I can get. So apart from the fact that the title of the post is the name of a twenty one pilots song which I really like, I also want to talk about some ideas which have been zooming around in my head. I don't really expect anyone to read this however I just want to document these ideas because they seem interesting to me in their own right. So I've recently been reading to and listening to many talks by Gabor Mate. What initially started as a want to closely understand ADHD (after my lowkey insane rant last time about neurodivergence which I almost considered deleting) led me to his book scattered minds (which ironically I didn't finish) but I have also been listening to a lot of his talks. Many of his ideas seem strikingly relevant to me.  One of these for example is how genetics only increase our predisposition towards certain diseases and are not determ
Read more

Why I want to (continue to) write this blog

Writing a blog is a rather daunting task. I mean, it probably shouldn't be considering that I have access to my working laptop and an internet connection. The daunting task occurs right before pressing the publish button as I contemplate on how much I will regret posting this blog as compared to the joy I would receive after broadcasting an idea I wanted to share with the world. This confusing calculus of cringing which I'm sure you have felt before posting something to your social media is what determines whether a blog post languishes along with my innumerable other drafts or gets to see the light of day. Even after I have posted something, I constantly wonder whether it is a good enough reflection of my ideas or should it be taken down. Being scared of what you post online is a feeling that we all relate to, but even though we all know the internet is a 'forever archive', there seems to be an irrational belief even past pragmatic considerations. And where there is an
Read more